Problem 354
Forum rules
As your posts will be visible to the general public you
are requested to be thoughtful in not posting anything
that might explicitly give away how to solve a particular problem.
This forum is NOT meant to discuss solution methods for a problem.
See also the topics:
Don't post any spoilers
Comments, questions and clarifications about PE problems.
As your posts will be visible to the general public you
are requested to be thoughtful in not posting anything
that might explicitly give away how to solve a particular problem.
This forum is NOT meant to discuss solution methods for a problem.
In particular don't post any code fragments or results.
Don't start begging others to give partial answers to problems
Don't ask for hints how to solve a problem
Don't start a new topic for a problem if there already exists one
Don't start begging others to give partial answers to problems
Don't ask for hints how to solve a problem
Don't start a new topic for a problem if there already exists one
See also the topics:
Don't post any spoilers
Comments, questions and clarifications about PE problems.
 BostonBear
 Posts: 17
 Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2011 4:48 am
 Location: Saugus, MA
Problem 354
This post is in regards to calculating B(1111111111). I had no problems finding out the method to calculate distances between the centers of 2 hexagons and creating a script to calculate B(sqrt(3)) and B(sqrt(21)) was straight forwards. But finding a distance between 2 hexagons that is equal to 111111111 has proven to be problematic. Its clear that when you break it into x**2 and y**2 = 111111111 that x has to be either an integer or a mutiple .5. Yet brute forcing it I was unable to find any solution whatsoever that lets 111111111 be a valid solution. I took into account rounding errors of square roots, etc but still no dice. If somebody could give me a hint on what I am doing wrong or give me one coordinate set that leads to that distance, I would be greatly appreciative.
Mike
Mike
Re: Problem 354
Can you find two hexagon centres that are exactly distance 3 apart?
Think about how would that might help.
Think about how would that might help.
_{Jaap's Puzzle Page}
Re: Problem 354
Does L has to be an integer or it can be a irrational number as well?
Re: Problem 354
The problem says "For a positive real number L"
puzzle is a euphemism for lack of clarity
Re: Problem 354
I have found a general formula for L (B (L) = 450). It seems to be more than one solution below 5*10^11. What number must be entered? Minimal? Maximum?

 Posts: 20
 Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2011 11:20 pm
Re: Problem 354
As the Problem states: You have to find the number of L <= 5 * 10^11, which hold B(L) = 450.

 Posts: 3
 Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2011 11:15 am
Re: Problem 354
It says to calculate for L <= 5.10^11
I presume in this context that dot means multiply?
So the value for L is 500 000 000 000?
I presume in this context that dot means multiply?
So the value for L is 500 000 000 000?
Re: Problem 354
I can find which ones are exactly 3 away, but it seems like the number of circles I can toss out within a hexring to capture centers increases as I go from one hexring to the next.
Last edited by Duality on Mon Nov 28, 2011 4:00 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Problem 354
I don't get how B(sqrt(21)) = 12
I make a grid. Then draw a circle going through the 7th hexagon directly above the queen and it doesn't intersect anything but the other 5 symmetrical bees. :/
I make a grid. Then draw a circle going through the 7th hexagon directly above the queen and it doesn't intersect anything but the other 5 symmetrical bees. :/
"Nothing in this world that's worth having comes easy"
Re: Problem 354
Have you looked carefully at the picture in the problem? It shows a length of sqrt(21).mctrafik wrote:I don't get how B(sqrt(21)) = 12
I make a grid. Then draw a circle going through the 7th hexagon directly above the queen and it doesn't intersect anything but the other 5 symmetrical bees. :/
_{Jaap's Puzzle Page}
 Lord_Farin
 Posts: 239
 Joined: Wed Jul 01, 2009 10:43 am
 Location: Netherlands
Re: Problem 354
It was helpful for me to realise that the side lengths of the hexagon are 1. This is not the same as the distance between two adjacent hexagons' center points being 2.
Re: Problem 354
Can somebody please clarify this to me:
A) Must we enter the total number (i) of Ls which satisfy B( L(1i) ) = 450 (Li : integer or real)? For example, if there were i=100 different Ls, integers or real numbers, and for each L is true that B(L(i)) = 450, then the answer would be 100.
OR
B) we seek something else (if yes please describe what)
Thanks in advance
Aris
A) Must we enter the total number (i) of Ls which satisfy B( L(1i) ) = 450 (Li : integer or real)? For example, if there were i=100 different Ls, integers or real numbers, and for each L is true that B(L(i)) = 450, then the answer would be 100.
OR
B) we seek something else (if yes please describe what)
Thanks in advance
Aris

 Posts: 5
 Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2011 6:36 pm
Re: Problem 354
In this problem , i can understand B(sqrt(3) = 6 and B(sqrt(12)), but how B(L) (any valid L) be any number other than 6 and 12 , because
For example let us take a hexagon whose sides are at a distance 'a' from the center, now let us chose a point at distance 'b' from the center (this point is not the mid point of any side nor any vertex of the hexagon) , so is it not right to say that there are only 12 such points on the hexagon???
Kindly explain
thanks in advance
For example let us take a hexagon whose sides are at a distance 'a' from the center, now let us chose a point at distance 'b' from the center (this point is not the mid point of any side nor any vertex of the hexagon) , so is it not right to say that there are only 12 such points on the hexagon???
Kindly explain
thanks in advance
Re: Problem 354
I think you're being sidetracked by symmetry.gnanasenthil654321 wrote:In this problem , i can understand B(sqrt(3) = 6 and B(sqrt(12)), but how B(L) (any valid L) be any number other than 6 and 12 , because
For example let us take a hexagon whose sides are at a distance 'a' from the center, now let us chose a point at distance 'b' from the center (this point is not the mid point of any side nor any vertex of the hexagon) , so is it not right to say that there are only 12 such points on the hexagon???
You can tile the plane with concentric rings of hexagonal cells. Each ring has 6way symmetry, and any hexagon you choose will have 5 or 11 symmetric brothers in that ring which are the same distance away from the center. However, there can be other symmetric groups of 6 or 12 which are the same distance from the center but part of other rings.
Re: Problem 354
Hi all,
First time post here, I feel like I've solved the problem mathematically, and I'm not getting the right number. So I'm looking to see if I'm missing something or not without giving away hints or violating ToS. First here are a few values of L which I believe give B(L) == 450, 44760094341, 139178767*sqrt(3), 179936733613*sqrt(3)
I have between 20 and 30 million such numbers of the right size.
I have the number of solutions for L <= 5*10^9 at 309767. Is this close? Does someone who has the right answer see something mathematical I'm missing or is this a painful bug?
First time post here, I feel like I've solved the problem mathematically, and I'm not getting the right number. So I'm looking to see if I'm missing something or not without giving away hints or violating ToS. First here are a few values of L which I believe give B(L) == 450, 44760094341, 139178767*sqrt(3), 179936733613*sqrt(3)
I have between 20 and 30 million such numbers of the right size.
I have the number of solutions for L <= 5*10^9 at 309767. Is this close? Does someone who has the right answer see something mathematical I'm missing or is this a painful bug?
Re: Problem 354
Those examples look good, but your counts are too low. You must be missing some of the Ls.AndyNovo wrote:First here are a few values of L which I believe give B(L) == 450, 44760094341, 139178767*sqrt(3), 179936733613*sqrt(3)
Re: Problem 354
For a L<=5*10^9, I get the answer as 1133713 and for L<=5*10^10 as 11623092. Could someone comment on it?
EDIT: Never mind. Those answers are wrong. Fixed a bug and finally got it.
EDIT: Never mind. Those answers are wrong. Fixed a bug and finally got it.
Re: Problem 354
I'm also thinking the same thing as you think, please somebody explain it.In this problem , i can understand B(sqrt(3) = 6 and B(sqrt(12)), but how B(L) (any valid L) be any number other than 6 and 12 , because
For example let us take a hexagon whose sides are at a distance 'a' from the center, now let us chose a point at distance 'b' from the center (this point is not the mid point of any side nor any vertex of the hexagon) , so is it not right to say that there are only 12 such points on the hexagon???
Kindly explain